tedwards/realms-in-ruin-dev
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Document Pass 11 Phase 1 synthesis and close static archaeology.

Browse Source 
Add executive summary and ability migration matrix; finalize evidence index, runtime validation plan, and Phase 1 handoff.

Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com>
This commit is contained in:
tedwards
2026-07-16 23:40:52 -07:00
co-authored by Cursor
parent 48d7a75149
commit aa0058a018
15 changed files with 2368 additions and 359 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
Documentation/Archaeology/15-HandoffStatus.md
+165 -79
View File
@@ -1,121 +1,207 @@
# 15 — Handoff Status
**Status: Draft**
**Status: Complete**
- **Scope:** Authoritative cross-model continuation document for Phase 1.
- **Scope:** Authoritative Phase 1 completion handoff for cross-model continuation into Phase 2.
- **Last updated:** 2026-07-16
- **Current phase:** Phase 1 — Static Architecture
- **Last completed pass / batch:** Batch 4D (Pass 4 + Pass 10)
- **Next authorized work:** Wait for user — **Pass 11** (synthesis / executive summary / Ability Migration Matrix) only when explicitly authorized
- **Current phase:** Phase 1 — Static Architecture (**complete**)
- **Last completed pass / batch:** Batch 5 / Pass 11 (synthesis)
- **Next authorized work:** Wait for user — **Phase 2A only** when explicitly authorized
## Phase completed
| Item | Value |
|------|--------|
| Phase | Phase 1 — Static Architecture (in progress; static archaeology complete pending Pass 11) |
| Batch completed | Batch 4D — Frontend/sessions + UI/HUD/pickups |
| Passes completed | Pass 4, Pass 10 |
| Phase | Phase 1 — Static Architecture |
| Phase status | **Complete** |
| Batch completed | Batch 5 — Synthesis |
| Passes completed | Passes 0–11 (Batches 1–5) |
| Date completed | 2026-07-16 |
| Model identifier | Cursor Grok 4.5 |
---
## Repository integrity
## Passes completed
### Starting state (Batch 4D)
| Batch | Passes | Focus |
|-------|--------|-------|
| 1 | 0–2 | Continuity; modules/config; native C++ |
| 2 | 3, 5 | BP hierarchy; BP_PlayerCharacterBase |
| 3 | 6 | Per-character abilities |
| 4A | 8 | Animation / AnimNotify |
| 4B | 7 | Partial GAS |
| 4C | 9 | Enemy AI static |
| 4D | 4, 10 | Frontend/sessions; HUD/pickups |
| 5 | 11 | Executive summary; migration matrix; final handoff |
- **Git:** Clean (`git status --short` empty; `git diff` / `git diff --cached` empty).
- **Authorization gate:** Batch 4C committed; Migration-Notes resolved; working tree empty before investigation.
- **Editor:** `IsPIERunning=false`; level `/Game/_Main/Levels/Testing/Test01`; selected actor `BP_Enemy_Skeleton_C_1`.
---
### Ending state (Batch 4D close)
## Documents created
- Modified files: Markdown under `Documentation/Archaeology/` only (listed below).
- Temporary scratch files `_tmp_pass4.txt` / `_tmp_pass10.txt` deleted if present.
| File | Role |
|------|------|
| Documentation/Archaeology/01-ExecutiveSummary.md | Phase 1 executive synthesis |
| Documentation/Archaeology/07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md | Final ability migration matrix |
(Other archaeology docs were created in prior batches.)
---
## Documents completed
| File | Status |
|------|--------|
| 00-MCP-Capability-Calibration.md | Complete (unchanged in Pass 11) |
| 00A-Phase-1-Execution-Plan.md | Execution plan (Batch 5 marked completed; not a result doc) |
| 01-ExecutiveSummary.md | **Complete** |
| 02-ProjectArchitecture.md | **Complete** |
| 03-ClassHierarchy.md | **Complete** |
| 05-LegacyAbilityArchitecture.md | **Complete** |
| 06-PartialGASArchitecture.md | **Complete** |
| 07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md | **Complete** |
| 08-CharacterSystems.md | **Complete** |
| 09-EnemyAI-StaticAnalysis.md | **Complete** |
| 10-AnimationDependencies.md | **Complete** |
| 11-UI-HUD-And-Sessions.md | **Complete** |
| 12-Pickups-And-Effects.md | **Complete** |
| 14-EvidenceIndex.md | **Complete** |
| 15-HandoffStatus.md | **Complete** (this document) |
---
## Documents remaining Draft
| File | Why Draft |
|------|-----------|
| 13-Unknowns-And-RuntimeQuestions.md | Runtime validation planned but **not executed**; remains the open runtime boundary |
---
## Repository state
### Starting state (Pass 11)
- **Git before gate commit:** Dirty — only `Documentation/Archaeology/00A-Phase-1-Execution-Plan.md` (Batch 4 complete status).
- **Gate commit:** `48d7a751` — Mark Batch 4 complete in Phase 1 execution plan.
- **After gate:** `git status --short` empty; diffs empty. Batch 4D docs already at `ee652712`.
### Ending state (Pass 11 close)
- Modified/created: Markdown under `Documentation/Archaeology/` only (Pass 11 synthesis set).
- No Unreal assets, source, config, plugins, or maps modified.
- PIE not started; level and selection unchanged at closeout check.
- PIE not started; level unchanged at closeout.
- Ending Git: Archaeology Markdown dirty only (expected before user commit request).
---
## Areas fully inspected (Batch 4D)
## Editor continuity
### Pass 4
- `GI_Dungeoneer`, `GM_MainMenu`, `GM_Dungeoneer`, `PC_MainMenu`, `PC_Character`
- `WBP_MainMenu`, `WBP_GameSlot`, `WBP_CharacterSelect`, `BP_MainMenuPawn`
- Session create/find/join completion/failure pins
- Maps MainMenu, Test01, Dev_Island, LEVEL_01 (GameMode via deps)
- `Config/*.ini` OnlineSubsystem / Steam / GameInstanceClass grep (negative)
- Example AdvancedSessions BP referencers
### Pass 10
- `WBP_PlayerHUD` CDO Overlay classes; `WBP_Overlay` tree + bar bindings
- `BP_OverlayWidgetController` (empty BP; native parent)
- `BPI_PlayerController` UpdatePlayerHUD / AddGold implementation status
- Four `RIREffectActor` pickups EventGraphs + CDO GE / replicate
- `BP_BasePickUp` / `BP_SmallGoldPickUp` gold + DEPRECATED health/mana paths
- UI inventory (pause missing; W_HUD_OLD unreferenced creator)
- Test01 placed pickup counts
## Areas partially inspected
- JoinSession internal travel (no explicit success pin)
- Remote-client character-select (server-only CreateWidget)
- Sphere collision profile / GenerateOverlapEvents (tool limit)
- LEVEL_01 menu reachability (no OpenLevel referencer found)
- WBP_BannerMessage / GameStats widgets (existence only)
## Areas not yet inspected
- **Pass 11** synthesis / `01-ExecutiveSummary` / `07-AbilityMigrationMatrix`
- PIE / standalone / multiplayer runtime
- Full CommonUI content usage
| Check | Result |
|-------|--------|
| IsPIERunning | false |
| Current level | `/Game/_Main/Levels/Testing/Test01` |
| Selected actors | Empty at Pass 11 continuity check (previously Batch 4D: `BP_Enemy_Skeleton_C_1`) |
| Editor mutation | None |
---
## Files updated
## Runtime work intentionally not performed
| File | Status |
|------|--------|
| Documentation/Archaeology/02-ProjectArchitecture.md | Draft (Pass 4 maps/config) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/03-ClassHierarchy.md | Draft (PC/GI/BPI holes) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/06-PartialGASArchitecture.md | Draft (Overlay + EffectActor Pass 10) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/08-CharacterSystems.md | Draft (char-select spawn) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/11-UI-HUD-And-Sessions.md | Draft (Pass 4+10 rewrite) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/12-Pickups-And-Effects.md | Draft (Pass 10 rewrite) |
| Documentation/Archaeology/13-Unknowns-And-RuntimeQuestions.md | Draft |
| Documentation/Archaeology/14-EvidenceIndex.md | Draft |
| Documentation/Archaeology/15-HandoffStatus.md | Draft |
- No PIE / Simulate / standalone / multiplayer sessions
- No compile or save of Unreal assets
- No Blueprint / GE / GA / tag / animation / widget / map / AI edits
- No OnlineSubsystem configuration changes
- Runtime validation plan written in doc 13 only
**09 not reopened** (pickup enemy ASC note only via 12/06).
**05 / 10 Animation** not modified.
**07 not created.** **01-ExecutiveSummary not created.**
---
## Key Batch 4D outcomes
## Major current-system conclusions
1. **Sessions live in menu PC/widgets**, not GameInstance; AdvancedSessions nodes connected; OnlineSubsystem project INI **Missing**.
2. **GI_Dungeoneer Present but Unconnected.**
3. **Pawn spawn:** DefaultPawn=None → character-select → SpawnActor+Possess (Gunslinger not in UI; char-select server-only create).
4. **ASC Overlay** Health/Mana connected statically; **no stamina widget**; Overlay class CDOs assigned.
5. **Legacy UpdatePlayerHUD and AddGold unimplemented** on `PC_Character` (not native either).
6. **Four GE pickups** Active static path with **Authority Risk**; gold Partial (AddGold hole); no other currency.
7. **Do not claim sessions or pickups work** without runtime testing.
1. Combat is **legacy Blueprint abilities** (IA → Server_Ability_* → Multicast montage → AnimNotify), not GAS activation.
2. Player ASC/AttributeSet on PlayerState are **Active**; consumable GEs are the only confirmed GE apply path.
3. Dual DEPRECATED vs ASC resources are **unsynchronized** (P0).
4. Amazonian Ability 001 is the only ability with supplied **Observed Runtime Behavior** confirmation.
5. Enemy chase/attack/damage reception are **Implementation Missing** (independent of GetASC defect).
6. Sessions graphs exist but OSS project INI is **Missing**; do not claim MP works.
7. Overlay Health/Mana connected statically; legacy UpdatePlayerHUD and AddGold **unimplemented**.
## Suggested next bounded task
---
**Authorize Pass 11 explicitly** (Phase 1 synthesis only), e.g.:
## Major defects
1. Create `01-ExecutiveSummary.md` / update synthesis docs
2. Create `07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md`
3. No PIE unless separately authorized
| Priority | Defect |
|----------|--------|
| P0 | Dual resource SoT; enemy damage/death missing; enemy chase/attack missing |
| P1 | Multicast notify gameplay/cleanup; EffectActor authority; GetASC nullptr; char-select MP; sessions/OSS; AddGold/UpdatePlayerHUD |
| P2 | Cleric 004 defects; orphan default GEs; stamina scaffolding |
| P3 | Naming/prefix debt; unused tags/cues/GI |
**Do not begin Pass 11 without explicit user authorization.**
---
## Ability migration summary
| Character | Disposition summary |
|-----------|---------------------|
| Amazonian 001 | Preserve behavior, migrate implementation (Phase 2C reference) |
| Paladin 001/003/004 | Preserve behavior, migrate implementation |
| Paladin 002 / Cleric partials | Reconstruct legacy behavior first, then migrate |
| Cleric 003 | Preserve behavior, migrate implementation |
| Wizard / Gunslinger stubs | Replace directly with GAS after framework |
| Wizard orphans | Defer pending design decision |
| Shared Multicast gameplay | Replace directly with native/shared framework |
| Dual resources | Reconstruct SoT in 2A first |
Full matrix: [`07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md`](07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md).
---
## Phase 2 recommended starting point
**Phase 2A — Baseline framework stabilization**
Establish canonical health/mana/stamina source of truth; default attribute initialization; legacy↔ASC transition policy; shared death/damage architecture; server-authoritative gameplay rules; reliable cleanup/interruption rules; repeatable runtime validation harness.
Do **not** begin per-character implementation until these contracts are approved.
---
## Required runtime-validation gates
Before trusting modernization claims, execute (when authorized) the grouped tests in [`13-Unknowns-And-RuntimeQuestions.md`](13-Unknowns-And-RuntimeQuestions.md):
1. Attributes/HUD → 2. Ability authority → 3. AnimNotify → 4. Interrupt cleanup → 5. Player death → 6–7. Enemy ASC/damage → 8. Pickups → 9. Char-select MP → 10. Sessions → 11. Gold → 12. Respawn/HUD.
---
## Tool limitations
- CustomEvent Reliability flags not exposed via MCP
- AnimGraph / Death transition DSL empty
- Montage notify trigger times require Manual Editor
- Sphere CDO collision often unreadable
- Semantic Search unavailable in prior passes
- A blocked read-only query is a tool limitation, not evidence of mutation
---
## Exact next action
Begin Phase 2A with a bounded runtime-baseline and shared resource-authority design pass. Do not begin per-character implementation until the canonical attribute, damage, death, authority, and cleanup contracts are approved.
**Do not begin Phase 2 without explicit user authorization.**
---
## Integrity statement
No Unreal assets, source, configuration, maps, plugins, or editor state were modified during Phase 1 archaeology (Passes 0–11). Only Markdown files beneath `Documentation/Archaeology/` were created or updated.
---
## Continuity checklist for next model
1. Read docs 00, 00A, 02–06, 08–15 (and 11–12 as primary Batch 4D deliverables).
1. Read `01-ExecutiveSummary.md`, `07-AbilityMigrationMatrix.md`, `13`, `14`, `15`, then domain docs as needed.
2. Confirm git status before any work; only Archaeology Markdown may change unless user expands authorization.
3. Confirm PIE stopped; level Test01 unless user changed it.
4. Pass 11 = synthesis only — no Unreal mutation, no PIE unless authorized.
4. Phase 2A = design + bounded runtime validation harness — not full character implementation.
5. Wait for explicit authorization before Phase 2.