realms-in-ruin-dev/Documentation/Archaeology/05-LegacyAbilityArchitecture.md

05 — Legacy Ability Architecture

Status: Draft

• Scope: Shared BP_PlayerCharacterBase ability architecture (Batch 2) plus per-character Ability 001–004 connected-path reconstruction (Batch 3 Pass 6), qualified by animation-notify wiring (Batch 4A Pass 8) and Pass 7 legacy/GAS boundary clarification.
• Inspection method: BlueprintTools connected subgraphs (Pass 6); AnimNotify Received_Notify DSL + montage dependency/referencer graphs (Pass 8); Pass 7 GAS GE/ASC inventory correlation.
• Evidence classifications used: Observed Implementation, Documented Intent, Observed Runtime Behavior, Inferred, Unknown.
• Tool or visibility limitations: CustomEvent Reliable flags not exposed; Montage Notifies array / trigger times unreadable via ObjectTools; AnimGraph DSL empty.
• Last updated: 2026-07-16
• Current phase: Phase 1 — Static Architecture
• Last completed pass: Pass 7 (Batch 4B) — boundary clarification only; ability tables unchanged
• Next pass expected to contribute: Pass 11 migration matrix / other Batch 4 passes when authorized

Draft tracking

Completed sections

• Shared input → Server RPC routing on base
• Base Server_Ability_* stubs
• Multicast FX helpers
• Death / respawn / HUD (DEPRECATED floats)
• Per-character Ability 001–004 connected paths for all five playables
• Parent-call inventory
• Resource / damage / projectile inventories
• Montage dependency seeds
• Pass 8: UseAbility* callers resolved (AN_Ability_001–004); AN_AttackComplete cleanup; Pass 6 reclassification table in 10
• Pass 7: Legacy vs GAS dual-resource boundary clarified (no ability-graph GE/ASC usage)

Pending sections

• Cross-character migration matrix (Pass 11 → doc 07)
• Runtime verification of CDO damage/mana values (PIE)
• Interrupt cleanup if AN_AttackComplete skipped

Evidence still required

• Notify trigger times (Manual Editor Inspection)
• FCanUseMana implementation body (call sites only)
• Client_Charge timeline numeric details
• PIE: potion ASC Health vs DEPRECATED_CurrentHealth divergence

---

Shared architecture (Batch 2 baseline — verified)

flowchart TD
  IA[IA_Ability_001to004] -->|Started| SBegin[Server_Ability_N_Begin]
  IA -->|Completed_or_Canceled| SEnd[Server_Ability_N_End]
  SBegin -->|base| Print[PrintString Override]
  SBegin -->|child override| Child[Character body]
  Child --> MC[Multicast_PlayMontage]
  MC --> AN[AN_Ability_00N notify]
  AN --> Use[UseAbilityN Authority]
  Use --> Dmg[ApplyDamage or RecoverHealth]
  MC --> ANC[AN_AttackComplete]
  ANC --> Clear[SetIsAttacking clears CurrentlyAttacking]

Observed Implementation: No UGameplayAbility activation. Reliability: Unknown — MCP property visibility limitation.

Pass 8: UseAbility* is invoked from AnimNotify Blueprints (AN_Ability_001–004), not from AnimBP EventGraphs. Multicast_PlayMontage completion pins are unwired — cleanup for notify-driven attacks uses AN_AttackComplete → SetIsAttacking. Full animation tables: 10-AnimationDependencies.md.

Base event	Body
Server_Ability_*_Begin	PrintString "Override Ability N"
Server_Ability_*_End	then unconnected
Multicast_PlayMontage / PlaySFX / Multi_SpawnParticle	Active helpers

---

Parent-call inventory (Pass 6)

Character	Ability overrides call Parent?	Other Parent calls
Paladin	No on Ability Begin/UseAbility	Tick/Overlap call Parent; BeginPlay does not (leader-pose style local)
Amazonian	No	—
Cleric	No on any ability override	BeginPlay no Parent (leader pose)
Wizard	N/A (no ability overrides)	BeginPlay no Parent; Tick/Overlap call Parent
Gunslinger	N/A	BeginPlay/Tick/Overlap call Parent

---

Player_Paladin

Path: /Game/_Main/Blueprints/Characters/PlayerCharacters/PlayerCharacterClasses/Paladin/Player_Paladin

Slot/System	Entry point	Parent called	Server path	Multicast/client path	Validation	Resource	Damage/effect	Animation	End/cleanup	Status	Evidence
Ability 001	Server_Ability_001_Begin; UseAbility001	No	Gate !attacking && !dead → CurrentlyAttacking → SetPlayerCanMove(true) → Multicast_PlayMontage(random Ability001Montages)	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate only	None	UseAbility001 Authority BoxOverlap ApplyDamage — caller: AN_Ability_001	Attack_A/B/C/D_Fast_Montage	AN_AttackComplete → SetIsAttacking (no local End)	Implemented (Pass 8 qualified)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 002	Server_Ability_002_Begin; Server_Ability_002_End	No	Begin: gate → CurrentlyAttacking → CanMove false → IsBlocking true	ABP Block (no Montage)	Gate	None	Block state only	ABP_Paladin Block via IsBlocking	End clears attacking/CanMove/IsBlocking	Partial	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 003	Server_Ability_003_Begin; Charge; Client_Charge; ChargeBox overlap	No	Gate → FCanUseMana → Charge + Client_Charge	Client_Charge	Gate + mana	DEPRECATED_Ability003ManaCost	ChargeBox Authority ApplyDamage	ChargeTimeline (not Montage)	Not notify-driven	Implemented	Pass 6
Ability 004	Server_Ability_004_Begin; UseAbility004	No	Gate → FCanUseMana → Multicast_PlayMontage(Paladin_Ability004_Montage)	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate + mana	DEPRECATED_Ability004ManaCost	UseAbility004 Authority AoE — caller: AN_Ability_004; empty particle	Paladin_Ability004_Montage	AN_AttackComplete cleanup	Implemented (Pass 8 qualified; FX hole)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Basic attack	Same as Ability 001	No	Same	Same	Same	Same	Same	Attack_* montages	Same	Implemented (=001)	—
Passive	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	—
Death	Inherited PlayerDeath	—	Base	Base	—	DEPRECATED health (if damaged via AnyDamage — Paladin has no local AnyDamage)	Base	Base	Base	Inherited	list_events
Legacy HUD	Inherited Server_UpdateHUD	—	Base DEPRECATED floats	—	—	Reads DEPRECATED health/mana	—	—	—	Inherited	Batch 2

Paladin montages:
/Game/_Main/Animations/PlayerCharacters/Human/CharacterClasses/Paladin/AnimMontages/Attack_{A,B,C,D}_Fast_Montage
/Game/_Main/Animations/PlayerCharacters/Human/CharacterClasses/Paladin/AnimMontages/Abilities/Paladin_Ability004_Montage

---

Player_Amazonian

Path: /Game/_Main/Blueprints/Characters/PlayerCharacters/PlayerCharacterClasses/Amazonian/Player_Amazonian

Slot/System	Entry point	Parent called	Server path	Multicast/client path	Validation	Resource	Damage/effect	Animation	End/cleanup	Status	Evidence
Ability 001	Server_Ability_001_Begin; UseAbility001	No	Gate → CurrentlyAttacking → CanMove true → Multicast_PlayMontage(random Ability001Montage)	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate	None	UseAbility001 Authority BoxOverlap ApplyDamage — caller: AN_Ability_001	A_Hu_F_Combat_2H_Attack* montages	AN_AttackComplete → SetIsAttacking	Implemented (Pass 8 confirmed)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 002–004	Inherited only	N/A	Base PrintString	—	—	—	—	—	Base empty End	Stub (inherited)	list_events
Basic attack	Ability 001	No	Same	Same	Same	Same	Same	Attack montages	Same	Implemented (=001); Observed Runtime Behavior: known working melee	parity brief + subgraph
Passive	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	—
Whirlwind	PerformingWhirlwind Get only	—	—	—	Gates AnyDamage	—	—	—	Never Set	Partial / Present but Unconnected setter	find_nodes
Death	ReceiveAnyDamage → PlayerDeath	—	Local health subtract DEPRECATED_CurrentHealth → Server_UpdateHUD → PlayerDeath if ≤0	Base death	PlayerHitCheck when whirlwind	Writes DEPRECATED_CurrentHealth	ApplyDamage inbound	—	Base	Partial (legacy health)	subgraph
Legacy HUD	Server_UpdateHUD after damage	—	Base	—	—	DEPRECATED health	—	—	—	Active	subgraph

Amazonian montages:
/Game/_Main/Animations/PlayerCharacters/Human/CharacterClasses/Amazon/AnimMontages/A_Hu_F_Combat_2H_Attack01_Montage (+ Attack02, Attack_Base, Attack)

---

Player_Cleric

Path: /Game/_Main/Blueprints/Characters/PlayerCharacters/PlayerCharacterClasses/Cleric/Player_Cleric

Slot/System	Entry point	Parent called	Server path	Multicast/client path	Validation	Resource	Damage/effect	Animation	End/cleanup	Status	Evidence
Ability 001	Server_Ability_001_Begin	No	Gate → CurrentlyAttacking → CanMove false → Multicast_PlayMontage(random Ability001Montages)	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate	None	AN_Ability_001 present but UseAbility001 unimplemented — no hit	Cleric_PrimaryAttack_*	AN_AttackComplete still clears attacking	Partial (montage + dead notify)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 002	Server_Ability_002_Begin; UseAbility002	No	Gate → FCanUseMana → Multicast_PlayMontage(Cleric_Ability002_Montage)	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate + mana	DEPRECATED_Ability002ManaCost	UseAbility002 Authority heal — caller: AN_Ability_002; empty particle	Cleric_Ability002_Montage	AN_AttackComplete	Partial (notify-driven heal; FX hole)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 003	Server_Ability_003_Begin; Server_Ability_003_End; ConcentrateHandle; EndConcentrate	No	Mana≥cost → DivineCircleActive + SetTimer 0.25 ConcentrateHandle	ConcentrateHandle plays montage + ApplyDamage; ABP Divine Circle state	Gate + mana	DEPRECATED_Ability003ManaCost	ApplyDamage in timer; AN_Ability_003 → UseAbility003 dead/vestigial	Cleric_Ability003_Montage (timer byproduct)	EndConcentrate	Implemented (timer-driven; vestigial notify)	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Ability 004	Server_Ability_004_Begin; UseAbility004	No	Gate → FCanUseMana called but Branch Condition=literal true → montage	Multicast_PlayMontage	Gate; mana bypassed	DEPRECATED_Ability004ManaCost unused	UseAbility004 — caller: AN_Ability_004; SpawnActor Class empty	Cleric_Ability004_Montage	AN_AttackComplete	Partial / Existing Baseline Defect	Pass 6 + Pass 8
Basic attack	Ability 001 montage	No	Same	Same	Same	—	Missing hit	PrimaryAttack montages	—	Partial	—
Passive	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	—
Death / HUD	Inherited	—	Base	Base	—	—	—	—	—	Inherited	—

Cleric GE GE_Cleric_DefaultAttributes exists but 0 referencers; not in ability graphs.

---

Player_Wizard

Path: /Game/_Main/Blueprints/Characters/PlayerCharacters/PlayerCharacterClasses/Wizard/Player_Wizard

Slot/System	Entry point	Parent called	Server path	Multicast/client path	Validation	Resource	Damage/effect	Animation	End/cleanup	Status	Evidence
Ability 001–004	Inherited Server_Ability_* only	N/A	Base PrintString	—	—	—	—	—	Base empty End	Stub (inherited PrintString)	list_events + EventGraph walk
Basic attack	Same	N/A	Stub	—	—	—	—	—	—	Stub	—
Passive	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	—
Death / HUD	Inherited	Tick/Overlap Parent yes; BeginPlay no Parent	Base	Base	—	—	—	—	—	Inherited	subgraph
Alternate paths	UseAbility* false; no Input/Montage/spell nodes	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	find_nodes
Unwired assets	NS_Wizard_Ability001; GE_Wizard_DefaultAttributes; BP_PlayerProjectile	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Present but Unconnected	deps/referencers

Local vars EnemyFound, IsBlocking, ClosestEnemy: declared, zero EventGraph uses.

---

Player_Gunslinger

Path: /Game/_Main/Blueprints/Characters/PlayerCharacters/PlayerCharacterClasses/Gunslinger/Player_Gunslinger

Slot/System	Entry point	Parent called	Server path	Multicast/client path	Validation	Resource	Damage/effect	Animation	End/cleanup	Status	Evidence
Ability 001–004	Inherited only	N/A	Base PrintString	—	—	—	—	—	Base empty End	Stub (inherited)	IsDataOnly + deps
Basic attack	Inherited stub	N/A	Stub	—	—	—	—	—	—	Stub	—
Passive	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	—
Death / HUD	Inherited; BeginPlay Parent	Yes	Base	Base	—	—	—	—	—	Inherited	subgraph
Weapon/projectile	None	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	Missing	deps only base

IsDataOnly=True. No GE_Gunslinger. Referencers registry [].

---

Cross-character RPC inventory (ability-related)

Event	Paladin	Amazonian	Cleric	Wizard	Gunslinger
Server_Ability_001_Begin	Local override	Local	Local	Inherit stub	Inherit stub
Server_Ability_001_End	Inherit empty	Inherit empty	Inherit empty	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_002_Begin	Local (block)	Inherit stub	Local	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_002_End	Local	Inherit	Inherit empty	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_003_Begin	Local (charge)	Inherit	Local (DivineCircle)	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_003_End	Inherit	Inherit	Local → EndConcentrate	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_004_Begin	Local	Inherit	Local (mana bypass)	Inherit	Inherit
Server_Ability_004_End	Inherit	Inherit	Inherit	Inherit	Inherit
UseAbility001	Local Authority damage	Local Authority damage	Missing	Missing	Missing
UseAbility002	Missing	Missing	Local Authority heal	Missing	Missing
UseAbility004	Local Authority AoE	Missing	Local Authority spawn broken	Missing	Missing
Charge / Client_Charge	Local	—	—	—	—
ConcentrateHandle / EndConcentrate	—	—	Local	—	—

Reliability: Unknown — MCP property visibility limitation for all CustomEvents.

---

Resource and legacy-state inventory

Symbol	Readers/Writers	Notes
DEPRECATED_Ability001Damage	Paladin UseAbility001; Amazonian UseAbility001	ApplyDamage BaseDamage
DEPRECATED_Ability003Damage	Paladin ChargeBox	ApplyDamage
DEPRECATED_Ability004Damage	Paladin UseAbility004	ApplyDamage
DEPRECATED_Ability002Damage	Cleric UseAbility002	Heal amount via RecoverPlayerHealth
DEPRECATED_Ability00{2,3,4}ManaCost	Paladin 003/004; Cleric 002/003/004	FCanUseMana / compare
DEPRECATED_CurrentHealth	Amazonian AnyDamage	Subtract + death check
DEPRECATED_RecoverPlayerHealth	Cleric UseAbility002	Interface message
CurrentlyAttacking / IsDead	All ability gates	Replicated on base
IsBlocking	Paladin 002 Begin/End	Local; ABP_Paladin Block state (Pass 8 Observed Implementation)
PerformingWhirlwind	Amazonian AnyDamage	Get only — never Set; not in AnimBP/montages (Pass 8)
DivineCircleActive / TimerHandle	Cleric 003	Timer loop; ABP_Cleric Divine Circle state reads flag (Pass 8)

No ASC attribute reads/writes in ability graphs. No GameplayAbility grant/activate.

Pass 7 — Legacy vs GAS boundary (clarification)

Concern	Legacy ability path	GAS path	Sync
Combat damage / heal	ApplyDamage / DEPRECATED_Recover*	Consumable GEs only (potions/food)	None observed
Mana cost	DEPRECATED floats + FCanUseMana	Attribute Mana modified by potions only	None observed
Default spawn resources	Not from abilities	Orphan GE_*_DefaultAttributes; native AttributeSet Init* used	Defaults unreachable via GE
UI	Server_UpdateHUD DEPRECATED %	OverlayWidgetController ASC	Dual, unsynchronized

Pass 9 — Player ApplyDamage vs enemy reception

Playable Paladin/Amazonian/Cleric attacks apply ApplyDamage (Pass 6). Enemy Blueprints implement no ReceiveAnyDamage / health mutation / death. Enemy ASC Health is not bridged from ApplyDamage. Static implication: player attack damage paths have no observed enemy health/death consumer — Existing Baseline Defect on the enemy side; player attack graph status unchanged.

Full matrices: 06-PartialGASArchitecture.md, 09-EnemyAI-StaticAnalysis.md. Ability status labels from Pass 6/8 are unchanged by Pass 7/9.

---

Authority / networking findings (flags, no fixes)

• Client IA → Server Begin: Observed Implementation
• Damage on UseAbility* / ChargeBox: Authority SwitchHasAuthority — Observed Implementation
• Multicast used for montage/SFX/particle presentation — Observed Implementation
• Pass 8: Multicast montage → AnimNotifies fire on evaluating machines; gameplay still Authority-gated inside UseAbility* / SetIsAttacking
• Pass 8 static risk: hit windows depend on server evaluating Multicast montage notifies; interrupt may skip AN_AttackComplete (completion pins unwired)
• Cleric Ability 004: mana CanUse unwired (literal true) — Existing Baseline Defect
• Cleric Ability 004: SpawnActor Class empty — Existing Baseline Defect
• Multi_SpawnParticle EmitterTemplate empty (Paladin 004, Cleric 002) — Partially Implemented
• End events missing for most slots — Incomplete Refactor (cleanup often via AN_AttackComplete instead)
• Amazonian/Paladin Ability 001: no mana cost — Observed Implementation
• Dual HUD still uses DEPRECATED floats on Server_UpdateHUD — Incomplete Refactor (Batch 2)

---

Status rollup

Classification	Characters / slots
Implemented	Paladin 001, 003, 004 (FX hole on 004); Amazonian 001; Cleric 003 (timer; vestigial AN_Ability_003)
Partial	Paladin 002; Cleric 001 (dead notify), 002 (heal + FX hole), 004 (broken spawn); Amazonian whirlwind
Stub	Wizard 001–004; Gunslinger 001–004 (inherited PrintString)
Missing	Wizard/Gunslinger combat bodies; most Server Ends
Present but Unconnected	NS_Wizard_Ability001; GE_* orphans; BP_PlayerProjectile; PerformingWhirlwind setter; Cleric_Hu_M_Spell_Staff_Up_Impact_Montage (0 refs)
Deprecated connected	All DEPRECATED_* damage/mana/health in active paths
Notify Present; Receiver Unimplemented	Cleric AN_Ability_001 → UseAbility001; Cleric AN_Ability_003 → UseAbility003

---

Pass 8 animation callback note

Full tables and reclassification: 10-AnimationDependencies.md. Primary status labels unchanged except qualifications above; no silent rewrites.

---

Migration relevance (inventory only)

Replacement targets: IA→Server custom events; AnimNotify→UseAbility timing; ApplyDamage/RecoverPlayerHealth; FCanUseMana + DEPRECATED costs; Multicast_PlayMontage; Charge timeline; DivineCircle timer; dual HUD floats; AN_AttackComplete lockout cleanup.